
Let me completely clear on this point, Judge Sonia Sotomayor is qualified to sit on the Supreme Court. But let's be even more direct, Judge Sotomayor is more qualified to be a Supreme Court Justice than any of the current chair-warmers, never mind the lot of mediocrities, Republican Senators who are far less wise than Sotomayor. Make no mistake, the opposition to Sotomayor by the white-male Republican southern rump, is based faintly on ideological predispisition, the real animating motive is the fact that they are choking on the thought of their cleaning lady taking hold of power that they thought was reserved for the Brahmin class to which they belong.
There is simply no way to argue that Judge Sotomayor is unqualified to be Supreme Court Justice. Her experience, for SC Justice, far exceeds that of the currnet bench.
In making his first pick for the high court, President Obama emphasized Judge Sotomayor's "extraordinary journey" from modest beginnings to the Ivy League and to the pinnacle of the judicial system. She would be the first Hispanic justice in the court's history, and only its third woman. Casting her as the embodiment of the American dream, the president touched off a confirmation battle that he hopes to wage over biography more than ideology.
On the district court bench, Judge Sotomayor earned a reputation as a sharp, outspoken and fearless jurist, someone who does not let powerful interests bully, rush or cow her into a decision. An analysis of her decisions on the appellate court showed a largely mainstream jurist, who generally stuck closely to the facts in the case and favored narrow rulings over sweeping statements. Her most celebrated case was her ruling in 1995 in which she barred team owners from unilaterally doing away with the free agent and salary arbitration systems, a finding that cleared the way for the end of the strike that had cancelled the 1994 World Series.
Never mind, that the good lady was a prosecutor, practiced commercial law with a white-shoe firm and then went on to become a trial judge and an appellate Court Judge. It would be hard to find someone with this breath of experience, let along a Puerto Rican Woman from the Bronx to fit the bill. As each hypocritical white male Republican drones on about her "wise Latina" remark, pretend you are seeing this in 1955, which is where most of her opponents continue to inhabit. As Bobby Dylan said, the times they are changin'and they will continue to change. Clarence Thomas was a place-holder, Judge Sotomayor is the future. Get used to it.
No comments:
Post a Comment